# How the Logbook picks products

> The Logbook is a weekly reading guide, not a leaderboard. Votes are too thin to rank anything, so the shortlist comes from a written standard instead. Here it is in full, so you can disagree with it.

Canonical: https://shipstry.com/logbook/standards
Last updated: 2026-10-15

## What we look for

### A narrow problem, stated plainly

We pick products that name a specific job — a phone number to unmask, a brief to lock, a budget to convert into days. A listing that describes a category rather than a situation gives us nothing to judge.

### A promise a reader can check

A number with a unit, a named platform, or a named counterparty. "1.3 seconds, works with Verizon" can be tested. "All-in-one studio" cannot, and could describe any product in the same batch.

### Evidence the maker wrote it themselves

Ship notes that explain who the product is for and what it refuses to do. Length alone does not earn a pick; a specific paragraph does.

## What we exclude

### Model-version resale pages

Listings named after another company's model release rather than after a problem. They arrive in batches, they are usually the same page with a new name, and they make a launch board look busier than it is.

### Quiz and answers content sites

Pages whose product is a search query — IQ tests, trivia, answer keys. They pass every form check and still are not tools anyone would open twice.

### Directories and launch boards

Products whose job is listing other products. They are legitimate businesses; they are not what this section is for, and covering them would make the section about itself.

### Duplicate and re-listed entries

The same product listed again under a new name or a modified slug. When we find one in a week's batch, we say so in the issue rather than quietly dropping it.

## Rules we hold ourselves to

### Every pick carries a caveat

A recommendation without a downside is an advertisement. Each product in the shortlist gets a sentence about where it is weak, unproven, or simply not for you, and the draft cannot be published until that sentence exists.

### Corrections are appended, never rewritten

A published issue stays as it was published, because it describes a specific week. If we got a fact wrong, the correction is added with a date. We do not silently edit history, and we do not remove an issue because someone would prefer it gone.

### Paid submission tiers never affect selection

Harbor, Voyage and Flagship buy review speed and scheduling. They do not buy a pick, a vote, or a mention. This is not only a promise: the selection code is not given the tier, the vote count, or the featured status of a product, so a paid listing cannot influence a pick even by accident.

### No applications, no payment, no exceptions

Products are considered automatically once they are approved and scheduled into a ship week. We do not accept submissions to be considered, and there is no route to a pick that involves paying us, sending us a draft, or asking twice.

## Guest posts and sponsored placements

We accept guest articles, and we sell sponsored placements elsewhere on the site. Both are labelled as what they are, and neither is a Logbook pick. Sponsored links carry a rel="sponsored" attribute; a guest post carries its author. A product cannot become a pick by appearing in either, and a pick cannot be turned into a sponsored slot.

## If your product was not picked

It usually means one of two things: the listing described a category rather than a situation, or the week had four products that did it better. Neither is a verdict on the product. Rewrite the sentence above your product name, keep shipping, and the next week's batch is a clean slate.

## Related

- [Logbook issues](https://shipstry.com/logbook)
- [Explore the registry](https://shipstry.com/explore)